top of page
Annie

Breaking Down Brick Walls: How Ancestry DNA Testing Can Solve Family Mysteries

In the quest to uncover my family history, I started with the traditional sources like birth certificates, census records, and old photographs. However, a couple years ago, I asked for a DNA testing kit for Christmas. DNA testing has emerged as a powerful tool that can significantly enhance our understanding of our ancestry. By analysing our genetic code, we can confirm family connections, gain insight into our ethnic origins and even discover previously unknown relatives. In this blog post, we’ll explore how DNA testing is revolutionising family history research and how you can use it to help build your family tree.


A blue strand of DNA spiral that has bumps along it on a white background

Understanding the Basics of Ancestry DNA Testing

Firstly, it's important to go back to basics and understand what DNA is. DNA, or deoxyribonucleic acid, is the hereditary material in humans that carries our genetic information. It is passed down from our parents, which means that our DNA contains traces of our ancestors’ genetic material. There are several types of DNA tests used in family history research, each providing different types of information:


  1. Autosomal DNA Tests: These are the most common types of DNA tests offered by companies like AncestryDNA, 23andMe, and MyHeritage. Autosomal DNA tests analyse the 22 pairs of chromosomes (excluding the sex chromosomes) inherited from both parents, making them useful for identifying relatives up to five to six generations back. These tests provide a broad overview of your genetic makeup and can help you connect with a wide range of cousins.

  2. Y-DNA Tests: Y-DNA tests focus on the Y chromosome, which is passed directly from father to son. This test is only available to males and is used to trace direct paternal lines. It can provide insights into your patrilineal ancestry, connecting you with distant relatives who share a common male ancestor.

  3. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Tests: Mitochondrial DNA is passed from mother to child, and mtDNA tests can be taken by both males and females. These tests trace your direct maternal line, providing information about your mother’s maternal lineage and connecting you with distant relatives who share a common maternal ancestor.


A female laboratory scientist standing at a laboratory bench filled with beakers, vessels and jars.

The Benefits of Using Ancestry DNA in Family History Research

The integration of DNA testing into family history research offers several compelling benefits:


1. Breaking Down Brick Walls

Nothing is worse than hitting a brick wall in your lineage research and getting stuck in the mud for months. DNA testing can help break through these barriers by identifying genetic matches with other individuals who may have information about your shared ancestry. For example, if you have an unknown ancestor in your family tree, a DNA match with a distant cousin who has more information can help you piece together missing parts of the puzzle.


2. Confirming Family Connections

While paper records can sometimes be inaccurate, incomplete or just darn hard to decipher, DNA testing offers a scientific method for confirming familial relationships. For instance, if family stories suggests a specific ancestral connection, DNA testing can provide genetic evidence to support or refute that claim. This can be particularly valuable in cases of adoption, where DNA testing may reveal biological family members.


3. Discovering Unknown Relatives

One of the most exciting aspects of DNA testing, but also one you must be wary of prior to undertaking a test, is the potential to discover relatives you never knew existed. Many people have found distant cousins—or even close family members—through DNA testing. Whilst this can be an exciting opportunity for reconnect it can also be a cause for stress in peoples lives. By comparing your DNA with that of millions of others in testing databases, you can connect with people who share segments of DNA, indicating a common ancestor. This can lead to new family connections and the sharing of family stories, photographs, and history.


4. Learning About Ethnic Origins

Most DNA testing companies provide an ethnicity estimate, which gives a breakdown of your genetic heritage based on specific geographical regions. They do this by comparing your DNA similarities against others data, as such, as their volume of data changes so can the ethnicity results you have received. Whilst I haven’t experienced this myself I have heard of others changing. This information can offer insights or confirmation into your ancestral origins and migrations. While ethnicity estimates should be taken with caution due to their reliance on current genetic reference populations, they can still provide a fascinating glimpse into the broader context of your family history. I didn’t expect mine to come back with Balkan heritage, most likely from my maternal grandfathers side, but it was an interesting insight that now I can try find the people in my tree to match.


5. Mapping Your Genetic DNA Tree

Advanced DNA analysis tools allow genealogists to create genetic family trees or DNA trees, which show how different DNA matches are related to each other. By using shared DNA segments, you can group matches into specific branches of your family tree, helping to clarify how unknown matches might fit into your ancestry. This adds another layer of factual evidence to your tree, weeding out any errors from interpretation of documentation or incorrect linking of documents to people within your tree. DNA trees are particularly useful for those looking to build a comprehensive factual picture of their heritage.

When using DNA Trees it's important to remember that as the generational distance increases so does the accuracy. The general rule of thumb for the Autosomal DNA Testing is 5-7 Generations (approximately 150-200 years). On the other hand, for the Y-DNA Testing and Mitochondrial DNA testing it is potentially hundreds of generations, however, it is not as useful for confirming recent generations.


Getting Started with DNA Testing for Family History

If you’re ready to dive into DNA testing for family history research, here are some steps to get started:


  1. Choose a DNA Testing Service: Decide which type of DNA test is right for your research goals. Autosomal DNA tests are generally the best place to start for most people because they provide the broadest range of information. Popular DNA testing services include AncestryDNA, 23andMe, MyHeritage, and FamilyTreeDNA.

  2. Collect Your DNA Sample: DNA testing typically involves a simple cheek swab or saliva sample, which is then sent back to the testing company. The company will analyse your sample and provide your results, usually within a few weeks.

  3. Explore Your DNA Matches: Once your results are in, you’ll be able to see a list of people who share segments of DNA with you, indicating a common ancestor. Reach out to your matches and compare family trees to determine how you might be related.

  4. Use Third-Party Tools: Consider using third-party tools like GEDmatch or DNA Painter to analyze your DNA results further. These tools offer more advanced features for comparing DNA matches and creating visual representations of your genetic family tree.

  5. Document Your Findings: As with traditional genealogy research, it’s important to document your findings and keep track of any new information you uncover. Record the details of your DNA matches, any communication with relatives, and any new connections or insights you gain.


Ethical Considerations and Privacy

While DNA testing offers powerful tools for uncovering family history, it also raises important ethical considerations. When you submit your DNA for testing, you’re not only sharing your genetic information but also that of your close relatives. It’s important to consider the privacy implications and make informed decisions about sharing your results with others. Many DNA testing companies provide privacy settings that allow you to control who can see your information.



DNA testing has transformed the field of family history research, offering new opportunities to uncover the past and connect with relatives. Whether you’re just starting your genealogy journey or looking to break through a brick wall, DNA testing can provide valuable insights and new directions for your research and family tree. By understanding how to use DNA as part of your family history toolkit, you can unlock the secrets of your ancestry and deepen your connection to your roots.


Are you ready to start your DNA journey or have you already started? Share your experiences or ask questions in the comments below!

Comments


bottom of page